That's exactly where my mind went. Why does he want to trade his medium frame 357mag for a different medium frame 357 mag? Something doesn't quite jive there.The values of each revolver is about equal.
So why does a fellow who has a new EAA Windicator want to trade it so soon? Is it inaccurate, poor trigger, doesn't work properly, or maybe he just doesn't like how it handles.
You like your Taurus 65, its finish and it's buttery smooth trigger. So why would you want to trade it for something you're not sure about?
I would politely thank the gentleman for being interested in your excellent revolver, then pass.