I had same problem, but went with the 16" because I wanted a 92. I think the stock is 1" shorter on the 16, didn't know that at the time, doesn't seem to bother me. I am thinking of getting a stock off a 20" if it actually is longer. The 16 is nice handling and can easily be carried with barrel straight down. I had a 20" and sold it a few years back( stupid mistake). I like the 16 better