Congrats on your CCP,(in Ohio it's a CHL). Holsters are a real personal choice. You'll probably end up with a box full before you find the one that works for you. Good luck on your search. Oh, Welcome to both of you.
I"m sure others would agree that holsters are a very personal thing. Try a LGS that will let you take your gun in, try out the holster and practice drawing. Not many LGS's will do that, but that's where i buy my holsters.