I went to Academy this evening with intentions of returning with the poly judge, but to my surprise they also had the new S&W Governor. It was priced only $130 more than the poly judge, so I asked to see it. Weight was ok, it was overall larger than the judge, and felt good in the hand, however, the 6 shot cylinder was way to big, making this a very unlikely candidate for conceal carry, and IMO, unattractive looking. I tried to see where I would ever use 45acp ammo in it but failed to see the value in it, moon clips are a pain anyway. Needless to say I took home the poly judge and never looked back, can't wait to shoot it this weekend.