Wow that is some real bad luck there DN. I am not a Raging Judge expert - so hopefully some one on here will have some ideas. It is strange that Taurus would restamp or fix the engraving though. As far as 454 casull - I have heard of an occasional cylinder or bore problem with that load in other none Taurus revolvers, but not Taurus. How frustrating. I am up to about 500 rounds mix 45C and 410 in my model 4510 Judge - no issues.